Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via Film on Paper
Hello friends! And boy, could I use some friends right about now. It seems every weekend lately, something happens that just throws my whole life and focus for a loop. I just want a boring, normal weekend. All I want to do is watch movies, write, and work the day job. Is that too much to ask for? Apparently. So, to the ten people who read every blog post, I'm sorry for all the delays lately. I'm trying, just bare with me.
Warning: I'm going to be talking about a major plot twist in this movie. If you plan on seeing it and want to be surprised, stop reading. You have been warned.
Okay. So, 1992 was a rough place in the LGBTQ+ world. It wasn't quite as bad as the 70s and 80s, it was slowly getting better. It was slowly becoming more socially acceptable to be gay. Hate crimes and discrimination were still widely a thing. AIDS was still a problem, both medically and socially, as information on it was still new and not widely distributed yet among the masses. But we were still a few years away from mainstream celebrities coming out and gay characters being portrayed as positive or as protagonists on mainstream television.
In late 1993, President Bill Clinton signed "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" into law, which did nothing to curb the which hunts of gays in the military
Image by ABC 7 Chicago
I can only imagine what being Transgender was like in 1992. They had all the usual problems that homosexuals had to deal with, compounded with the stigma of Transgenderism. Popular media had portrayed Trans people as, at best, a joke. But at worst, like a serial killer. Movies like Psycho and Dressed to Kill are great films, but they helped infuse a discomfort in the minds of many that men who dress in women's clothing are mentally unstable. And of course, women who dress like men are just butch lesbians.
The reason I bring this up is that one of the main themes of this film is transgenderism and gender identity. One of the leads plays an MtF Transgender. I'll get into some specifics when I get into the plot, but it's handled in a very graphic and realistic way, much like the rest of this movie. Amazingly, it's just one of the issues tackled rather successfully in The Crying Game, along with sexual orientation, race, and nationality. So let's get into the plot.
I'm going to do something I normally don't want to do in these reviews. I order for some of my thoughts to make sense, I'm going to go into great detail about the story. So again, if you don't want more spoilers, go watch the movie and come back. You have been warned. Again.
Some film openings are so perfect, they stick with you forever.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
The movie starts with a beautiful panorama shot of a carnival by a river, with Percy Sledge's iconic "When a Man Loves a Woman" playing. Forest Whitaker and Miranda Richardson are at the carnival, having a good time. She sneaks him away, tempting him sexually. Once they are alone, several men come out and grab Whitaker and whisk him off to a hideout. Turns out he's a British soldier and he's been kidnapped by the Irish Republican Army (IRA). They are holding him hostage so the British government will release some IRA operatives from prison. They have three days, or Whitaker dies.
Whitaker and, likely, the audience knows what the end result will be. A soldier played by Stephen Rea is assigned to guard Whitaker. Over the course of those three days, they develop a close bond. They talk about Cricket. Whitaker relates the parable of the Scorpion and the Frog. He pleads for mercy, which Rea can't give him. Whitaker knows he's going to die, so he makes Rea promise to check in on his girl back home.
This is a decent chunk of the film. And an amazing performance with solid chemistry between the two
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
When the time comes, Rea leads Whitaker into the woods. Whitaker runs, knowing he can outrun Rea, who lets him go anyway. He can't go through with it. Whitaker runs to freedom, turns to celebrate and shows his thanks to Rea..... and promptly gets crushed by an Armored Personnel Carrier. The British Army showed up and they rain down indiscriminate hellfire upon the IRA hideout, not caring if Whitaker is still a prisoner or alive. Rea, who is in the woods and not at base, manages to slip away.
A man will do what's in his nature to do.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
Sometime later, Rea is in London. He uses an alias and has a job as a construction worker. He manages to track down Whitaker's girlfriend, played by Jaye Davidson. He kinda stalks her for a bit and follows her into a bar called The Metro. She fights with some guy, then they leave, and Rea follows. He ends up falling for her, protecting her from that violent suitor. Davidson is a hairdresser and sings at the bar sometimes. She does a strong cover of Dave Berry's "The Crying Game." Eventually, they are about to get down to business, and he pulls her pants down to reveal... a big ole' dick. Davidson is Transgender.
Trust me, it's not a trap.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
Rea has an extremely negative reaction to this big reveal. He hits Davidson then rushes to the bathroom to puke. Davidson, bawling, drops to her knees screaming "not again" and "how could you not know?" It's a raw, visceral, emotional scene, and not easy to watch. But it's a scene that resonates with the tragedy of realism. It's uncomfortable, but in the same way, something like, say, Schindler's List was as well. Though a different type of situation, obviously.
Rea eventually apologizes to Davidson, and the two continue their courtship. He puts on a bit of a front, but clearly is falling for her. But he hasn't told her the truth about himself or Whitaker yet. In one scene, he has her wear Whitaker's old Cricket jersey while they make love. Rea imagines it's Whitaker in her spot.
Don't you just love those earrings?
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
Rea misses the assassination because of all that. The IRA does the dead without him, and succeeded, but not without casualties. Richardson manages to get away though and goes hunting for Davidson and Rea. Richardson gets to Davidson's apartment, but Davidson is waiting for her. She shoots Richardson and then turns the gun on Rea. But she can't pull the trigger, because Whitaker "wouldn't let her." She breaks down. Rea takes the gun, wipes her handprints off it, and replaces them with his own. The police come and arrest him.
Fast forward a few months. Rea is in prison. Davidson comes to visit him. Rea still puts on a bit of a front, but it's clear he loves her. She asks him why he did what he did, taking the fall for her. He tells her it's just in his nature and begins to tell her the parable of the scorpion and the frog. The end credits start to roll with Lyle Lovett covering "Stand By Your Man." Wow.
Richardson kills in this movie.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
So, let me first address the elephant in the room. Some modern, more sensitive viewers might balk at the more transphobic scenes, especially the scene with the big reveal. Rea also puts up a fake attitude of bravado for most of the movie, denying he has any attraction to Davidson, though his actions say otherwise. And if this movie came out today, set today, I might be inclined to be uncomfortable with it. But remember the context. This wasn't 2020, this was 1992. I'm not saying transphobia and homophobia are good, but they were much more a thing then, so of course Rea is going to act as he did. The reveal scene is raw and graphic and dripping with authenticity. I would also argue that because his character does grow and overcomes most of his prejudice. He learns to follow his heart and fall in love with a Trans girl. Also, we have a Trans character that, while flawed, is still portrayed positively (aka NOT a serial killer) and that Rea falls in love with her, wow.
Some people might also accuse the Davidson character of being a "trap" because she doesn't tell Rea about her extra tool. Nope. He went with her, more than once, to what was clearly a drag bar. They do a good job of shooting it to keep the twist up, but still. I kinda suspected, just from the bar. Rea's character needs to be more observant. But the fact that he didn't know actually fits within his character. It's not a trap.
The second big theme of the movie is that of nationalism, in particular, "the Troubles" between the British government and the IRA. The IRA comes off as having a significant cause, but not caring who they hurt along the way. The British military, likewise, had a purpose but will murder indiscriminately. And soldiers of both sides can be good people, who get wrapped up in things beyond them. It's important to note that the IRA was going to kill Whitaker, but the British did it first. They are both guilty.
I forgot to mention that Jim Broadbent plays the bartender at The Metro. A small role, but I always love seeing him in things.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
Neil Jordan wrote and directed this film. He had a slew of interesting-sounding movies in the 80s and would go on to direct Interview with a Vampire after this. It shouldn't come as a surprise that he had trouble getting this film made. He initially came up with the idea in the early 80s, but with a female romantic lead instead of a Transgender. He had the idea for the change in 1991, while in Berlin to premiere his movie The Miracle.
Due to the controversial script, Jordan's last couple of movies not performing well financially, and doubt that he could find a convincing actor to play the twist, studios were hesitant to fund it. Then, Jordan found Davidson, who is gay but not Trans in real life. Sadly, he doesn't have more than just a couple of film credits, with his only other role of note being Ra in the Stargate movie in 1994.
The Crying Game had a budget of only £2.3 million. The costume designer, Sandy Powell, ended up having to loan Davidson some of her own clothes to wear, due to the tight nature of the budget.
The original title of the film was The Soldier's Wife. However, the name was changed based on a recommendation from Jordan's friend, the renowned director Stanley Kubrick. Kubrick told him that people would think it was a war film.
The movie was a flop in the UK, bringing in only £2 million after it was released on September 18, 1992. The political buttons it pushed made it a disaster when it was originally released. But when it came out in the US a month later, on October 30, it did far, far better. Due to it being billed as a sexual thriller, and US audiences not knowing or caring about "the Troubles," The Crying Game ended up grossing $62.5 million across the pond.
The US release poster, different from the UK one up above. Iconic and super noir-ish. I remember seeing this in newspaper advertisements.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via IMDB
Here are some neat YouTube behind-the-scenes videos. The 25th Anniversary Panel, a cool Where Are They Now vid, and also an interview with Richardson, Rea, and Jordan on Charlie Rose.
Lastly, I want to mention a couple of other things about the soundtrack, that I didn't mention when talking about the plot. It was produced by the super talented Anne Dudley and the Pet Shop Boys. And fun fact, Boy George did the vocals for the film version of the movie title track "The Crying Game." Davidson just lipsynchs. Bonus fun fact, it ended up being George's first hit single in five years.
Davidson sings in a club that is full of culture.
Image by Palace Pictures/Miramax via
Final Verdict:
Obviously, I love this movie. It's a masterpiece. The acting and writing and direction are superb. I had no idea about the twist going into it and, while I kinda saw it coming, it was still executed well. The music was great, from the opening "When a Man Loves a Woman" to the closing gender reversal version of "Stand By Your Man." I highly recommend this to everyone, unless you are easily and severely triggered by scenes of transphobia.
The Crying Game had a bit of personal resonance with me, as well. I'm not Transgender, but I have struggled with my gender identity, and I consider myself genderfluid. I sometimes like to wear dresses and I feel pretty in them when I do.
Being genderfluid is like a mixture of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Best of both worlds!
Image Source